I had all but abandoned this blog but today I am really fuming after I heard about Toukai TV’s decision to cancel the airing of the twelfth episode of Higurashi. For those of you who haven’t heard it yet – in a nutshell the story goes like this: girl kills father, girl says she has wanted to become mangaka, media fuels anti-anime hysteria, TV station gets scared and refuses to air the episodes of Higurashi and School Days for “various reasons”, fans of Higurashi and School Days are enraged.
Anyone sees the big problem in this story? I know, you will say the problem is that we can’t be certain whether the girl even watched these series, let alone got inspired by them in order to do her terrible crime. That’s part of the problem, yes. But the bigger problem is the sensaniolist, blood-hungry, disinforming, biased, full of hypocrites media. The fact that the more violent and sick the crime is, the more attention it receives in the news is sickening enough but the witch hunt that starts almsot every bloody time a shocking crime occurs is even worse. For crying out loud, there were gruesome murders in abundance long before there was anime or video games (or whatever modern influence the journalists choose to blame for the decay of youth depending on the case), yet if you listen to some “experts” you might get the impression that these harmless leisure activities are virtually the most likely source of making someone commit a murder (I am talking in general as I have no first impression of the media outrage that is currently going on in Japan but the results of it seem pretty indicative).
But I am going to go one step further and say boldly – I don’t care if the girl got inspired by Higurashi, Lord of the Rings, Grand Theft Auto or Mozart’s Requiem. The fact that millions of others did not is more than enough proof that the problem lies somewhere else, not with the hyphotetical influence. Moreover those who cannot make a difference between fiction and reality are already virtually insane anyway, no use blaming the straw that might have broken the camel’s back rather than think what might have made them dellusional in the first place. And if you going to blame the anime industry – fine, but be fair. Why start with this small fish and not with the big fish? You know what work of fiction has inspired and continues to inspire (on a smaller scale, thankfully) millions of people to massacre others? That’s right – The Bible. Or if one happens to be a Christian – The Quran. No one believes in them both, so at least one of them must be (mostly) fiction, right? So if the media watchdogs want to blame something – deal with the big issue first.
Or why don’t the media start a campaign against, say, Agatha Christie? In each of her mystery novels, someone gets murdered, usually in a very cunning fashion. The modus operandi of the murderer is described in detail. Using the same retarded logic that makes the journalists blame anime or video games or death metal lyrics for all knid of crimes, one can say that Christie’s books practically teach people how to murder and not get caught (since most detectives are nowhere near Poirot’s skills, after all). So what are you waiting for, media watchdogs? Start the campaign now!
Oh, but Christie does not glorify or justify violence, I hear you say. And Higurashi does? Without spoiling much, I can say that whenever a character in Higurashi goes on killing rampage, they are not portrayed in a symphatetic light and really regret their actions in the end, an end which is usually anything but happy for them. As for Christie, let’s just say that in one fo her most famous books, Poirot lets the culprits get away free after they have taken justice in their own hands and murdered a certain criminal. Do you think it’s likely the media will call for a ban of this book next time someone is lynched? Of course not, and that’s how it should be. But this shows the disgusting double standards of mainstream media.
OK, I had to get that off my chest, thank you for reading this rant and I hope I haven’t offended any religious people, it’s not religion which is the problem, it’s the double standards.
September 21, 2007 at 8:38 am
You have earned respect from me for mentioning Agatha Christie, one of my favorite authors of all time.
And speaking of Christie and Higurashi, the OP of the latest release from 7th Expansion, Umineko no Naku Koro ni, looks just like what I’d expect from an anime of “And Then There Were None”. Lol, just rambling now…
September 22, 2007 at 10:33 am
I’m so glad that someone is just as outraged as me. I’m still going to be stirring in anger for the next few days, but that helped
September 23, 2007 at 10:32 am
Seconded. I mean WTF?!? Hopefully other stations will be airing it…gomen, I’m not too well-informed.
September 25, 2007 at 1:33 am
the japanese media is rather fickle, they will sensationalize something for a week or so, in 3 weeks everyone forgets about it, so im expecting higu kai 12 in probibly a month or so. (they definatly wont drop a series this popular that gets the kind of raitings it does over a murder case witch hunt that everyone will forget in 2 weeks)
September 26, 2007 at 10:33 am
In the Philippines, Big Brother, a reality show where people who do not know each other live in one house filled with cameras for 100 days or more, was almost canceled because there was an event that two of the girl housemates kissed in the pool.
September 30, 2007 at 12:43 pm
This matter becomes even more silly, when people who doesn’t know a damn about the commotion just use it as the perfect opportunity to attack anime
I think you will probably frown a lot. Personally, my patience has been eroded quite considering the replies.
October 1, 2007 at 7:03 pm
It’s always sad how things like this get blown way out of proportion, and how people seem to accept it as is.
December 20, 2007 at 3:52 pm
Guess what? Your blog is amazing! I can’t remember when was the last time i’ve overcome such a good blog that almost all articles/posts were interesting and wouldn’t regret spending my time reading it. I hope you will keep up the great work you are doing here and i can enjoy my everyday read at your blog.
May 1, 2008 at 7:41 am
[…] seen to date. Okay, maybe not the best one. But this was definitely a case of going out on a last hurrah, but not one that said, “So long and thanks for all of the fish.” Matrim posted a […]
June 3, 2008 at 2:34 am
Preservable says : I absolutely agree with this !
October 22, 2014 at 5:37 pm
To listen to the inner call that may have been trying to get your attention.
In the game you command a World War II tank
charging to occupy the enemy capitol. My parrot has an exercise play station in the living room by the window.
November 19, 2014 at 7:26 pm
Hi high. My name is Yolonda need not totally love this logo.
Kentucky is the only place I’ve been residing in but I would
like to move for my loved one. Debt collecting has been my
profession for serious I assume I’ll put it back anytime soon. As a girl what I enjoy is carry out martial arts but Not able to make
it my profession really. I am running and maintaining a blog here:
http://nexhost.net/
April 8, 2016 at 3:00 pm
Yes, people have always liked “good” photos of themselves, and I agree with that. But someone asked me what I thought would be a healthier way of participating in Social Media and it seems obvious to me: concentrate less on portraying yourself online, and look at the world around you instead. Click http://link.mx/hool08200